Rules of Adultery?

topic posted Sun, August 19, 2007 - 12:05 PM by  Munk
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
So I'm in a rather unique situation with my FWB. He's married, though not very happily, and I'm there most every day caring for his child. Even though I don't see him that often, due to a heavy work load, when we do get to be together we both want to make sure things stay hush hush so no one gets hurt. We're not in love with each other, but there is a deep caring and the sex is mainly for comfort and mutual satisfaction. We're friends first and I'd like to inquire of other who might be in a similar situation if they have any advice? Thanks if you can help.

P.S. - Don't judge me since I wouldn't judge you.
posted by:
Munk
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Mon, August 20, 2007 - 8:35 AM
    "So I'm in a rather unique situation with my FWB. He's married, though not very happily, and I'm there most every day caring for his child."

    'k, here's the first question. WHY are you there most every day caring for his child. Are you the babysitter?

    "Even though I don't see him that often, due to a heavy work load, when we do get to be together we both want to make sure things stay hush hush so no one gets hurt."

    How old is the child? If we're talking infant here no worries, but if the child is old enough to get around on it's own he/she is *going* to figure out *something* is happening sooner or later. That would suck, for you, your lover, and neither should concern you as much as what it would do to the kid. My advice here is *cool it* around the child. It won't understand, and you could confuse and mess up a kid that way, which I'm sure you don't want to do.

    "We're not in love with each other, but there is a deep caring and the sex is mainly for comfort and mutual satisfaction."

    You can get that alot of places. It seems like here you're taking ALOT of chances for a very LITTLE return. (though of course I don't have all the details). If the marriage is that bad, in which he's coming to your bed for support and comfort because of it (I'm not judging, I've been that guy in the past) then as his *friend* I'd tell him to get the hell out before the whole thing blows up in his face, keep things AWAY from the child **IMPORTANT** and otherwise be there when you can. It will work, until it doesnt. (and it NEVER works forever). The only thing you ultimately have control over is wether you'll be friends when it's all said and done.

    We're friends first and I'd like to inquire of other who might be in a similar situation if they have any advice? Thanks if you can help.
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Mon, August 20, 2007 - 9:21 AM
    I'm not saying this as trying to judge you in anything that you're into, miss. Except to say that in such cases, it's very hard for both individuals to steer clear of the emotive aspect of your being with each other. One way or another, maybe next time the two of you meet, the issue of being with each other always is soon going to start rearing its head.

    But other than that, it's a good thing that the two of you have a regualr schedule of meeting. I'd advise that you make a change, just in case either him or yourself is being suspected by a third company.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Mon, August 20, 2007 - 4:02 PM
      I don't want to marry him, I'm just borrowing him. He's my closest male friend and that's how I'd like to keep it. One day we wont need each other in this way but our friendship will continue just fine. We're both very careful, but you can never be too careful.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Mon, August 20, 2007 - 5:53 PM
        This actually doesn't sound all that "unique" to me. Seems like you're following the traditional rules of monogamy and cheating there. I'm sure lots of folks are in very similar situations. How is it working for you?
        • Re: Rules of Adultery?

          Mon, August 20, 2007 - 6:33 PM
          It's working out nicely. We keep each other happy and satisfied when time allows. In a way, it does feel like I'm playing at being a wife. But I think of it more as practice for when I get married for real one day. Before we began this whole thing, I was clueless about relationships and the workings of the male mind. I've learned so much.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Tue, August 21, 2007 - 10:49 AM
        That's the main thing, isn't it: how careful can you truly be?
        • Re: Rules of Adultery?

          Tue, August 21, 2007 - 10:52 AM
          We're careful in a paranoid sort of way.
          • Re: Rules of Adultery?

            Tue, August 21, 2007 - 12:03 PM
            If I were you, I would feel bad about deceiving his wife. Personally, I like to create the world I want to live in around me, and so I wouldn't want to get involved in the lie. Does this ever bother you at all?
            • Re: Rules of Adultery?

              Tue, August 21, 2007 - 12:11 PM
              It bothers me all the time. That's why we're both careful to let no one find out and neither of us has any desire to give each other up. I thought many times of telling him I want to stop and I know he would respect my choice. We don't want to hurt anyone, just be happy with each other. In a perfect world that would be possible. But we have to work in the situation we live in and it works for us just fine.
              • Re: Rules of Adultery?

                Tue, August 21, 2007 - 1:36 PM
                Munk,
                It seems that with the very question "Rules of Adultery?" you are looking for validation of what you know is wrong.

                "We don't want to hurt anyone, just be happy with each other."

                Then maybe it's time you took the step of respecting the others that are involved unknowingly and have him officially separate from the person you are hiding from. Then the two of you can have a relationship in the open.

                There is no way that a situation like this ends with no one getting hurt. Whether it's you, him, or the other person who doesn't know there's a third person involved in her sex life - someone is going to get hurt.

                There are no "rules" to adultery because it's dishonest and secretive - thus by it's very nature breaking rules.
                • Re: Rules of Adultery?

                  Tue, August 21, 2007 - 2:40 PM
                  I already know it's wrong, but I'm not at the point where I'm willing to stop just yet. It is quickly becoming hurtful to me emotionaly since I know he has no desire to leave his wife and cozy domestic situation. I don't want him to. He should love her and stay with her. I know I'm selfish about wanting to spend time with him, but I have no desire to steal him away. He's my friend and so is she. I value that above all else we share. I have a feeling that I'll soon be ending it on my own to protect our friendship. No amount of sexy fun is worth ruining the close bond we've nurtured as friends first. I know he doesn't want me to hurt, he's told me so and said we didn't have to do any of it if I was uncomfortable. I'm just tormenting myself and he's given me multiple outs if I wanted them. I just have to come to it on my own and in my own time.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: Rules of Adultery?

                    Wed, August 22, 2007 - 8:47 AM
                    "He's my friend and so is she. I value that above all else we share. I have a feeling that I'll soon be ending it on my own to protect our friendship. No amount of sexy fun is worth ruining the close bond we've nurtured as friends first."

                    Well, good luck in keeping those friendships. It is likely that she will find out, it's unfortunate but it is true and I don't know anyone who would feel like they were treated like a friend by someone who was lying to them.

                    You need to do what you chose, but you need to really be comfortable with the likely consequences of your actions and your actions are likely to lead to the end of both of those friendships. It may not, but it is very likely.

                    Of course this is just my opinion, I could be completely wrong and everything could work out wonderfully.
          • Re: Rules of Adultery?

            Wed, August 22, 2007 - 10:53 AM
            Don't you think you can find someone who isn't married to still fulfil your every intentions? Looks like if you carry on with the way that you are, you're playing with matches.
            • Re: Rules of Adultery?

              Wed, August 22, 2007 - 1:10 PM
              I've attempted to in the recent past. But the idea of letting another man touch me that isn't him just made me feel repulsed. I think if I could emotionaly disconnect from him I wouldn't feel this way. I know there's plenty of guys just as good or better than he is and I shouldn't limit myself so much. But how do you let go?
              • Re: Rules of Adultery?

                Thu, October 11, 2007 - 10:03 AM
                Munk...with all respect sweetness...but i agree with angel...ange ...and with out judgeing..u want answers..thats the reason u placed this .....i understand u guys are friends and share alot...but im sure u dont do that with all ur close friends?..to be honest...u reslly dont care for his happyness,,knowing that the other party may find out one day...it can couse him more hurt and pain and bring him more drama...plus! a child is in the mix of all of this?! come one girl!! with all the dick in the world.u cant find one for-ur self..granted..if the other party was ok on u guys shareing each-other ...thats a diffrent story.. but ur not really careing..im sorry sweetie..been there done that...ur just useing ur friend as well as he is useing u...no matter how well u slice it!(wink)...........so lets be real about it.
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Tue, August 21, 2007 - 6:32 PM
    Well I am in a relationship with my man an another woman, I don't really believe in a one woman one man thing. Too many other factors come in that really mess that one up. Plus I think the idea of one man one women was ingrained into us from when we were children. Our parents learned it from their parents and so on... the root of that issue comes from religious ideals that were drawn from a time period where rich men wanted to keep their wifes from having sex outside the marriage. So the made decrees and pass laws that said you can have sex outside of your own marriage.

    The other part of this issue is that, even though its fun and its something that both of you want, its problematic going to complicate your lives to the point where the energy spent maintaining the illusion is going to be to much to handle.. I would take breaks from each other frequently and spend time do other things that are important to you, don't make the relationship the primary focus as that usually can be a cover for something problematic that sits deeper in your soul that you haven't dealt with yet.

    Hope things work out.

    P.S don't worry about people that are judging you, thats just a reflection for something they don't like in themselfs that is pretty similar to what you are going though right now. Its easy to say its wrong, but when you deep in the thick of it, it takes on a whole new meaning.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Tue, August 21, 2007 - 6:52 PM
      Thank you so much! You've said what I've believed for a long time. I don't believe in true love or one man for every woman. I believe each person is compatible with so many other types of people in the world. I would never be happy if I was stuck with one person for the rest of my life. I hate the whole idea of marriage. I find it restrictive and soul draining in the long term. I want to free to be with who I want with no strings attatched. No ring on my finger and no snot nosed kids clinging to me. I like kids, I just don't want to be stuck with one forever. But anyway, you're right, it's easy for people to judge even though they may have no clue what I'm going through. I would never be so bold to think I had any right to play the moral police to anyone.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Tue, August 21, 2007 - 9:57 PM
        Munk,
        For what it's worth I'm not advocating monogamy. I've been poly for years. Sometimes it works for me sometimes it doesn't.

        What I'm advocating is openness and honesty and you aren't doing that. My words are entirely in the context of the fact that his wife does NOT know about you and your sexual relationship with him.

        I wonder if you are using your own loneliness as an excuse to do what you "know is wrong" and make it seem ok.

        Either be open about it or stop.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Wed, August 22, 2007 - 9:09 AM
        "But anyway, you're right, it's easy for people to judge even though they may have no clue what I'm going through. I would never be so bold to think I had any right to play the moral police to anyone."

        First off, people do have a clue what you are going through. You've said what you are going through and I'm sure there are several people who have gone through similar situations. While a few of the specifics may be different it isn't like you are an alien life form engaging in a new dynamic.

        Second, what do you think about people who intentionally harm others? Do you think that's bad? Do you have no opinion on it?
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Wed, September 5, 2007 - 6:10 AM
        When you get a bit older, you will feel differently about your 'snot-nosed kids' and you'll be glad you've got them. The same can be said for a good relationship with a significant other. While the butterfly is young it regales in flitting from one flower to another, but nothing remains young for ever. Everyday I give thanks for the existence of my grand children - they make my life meaningful and fun, and I couldn't live without them. Just my two cents worth.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Tue, August 21, 2007 - 6:54 PM
      I only see him maybe once a week if I'm lucky since he works so much. And I'm always busy with other activities. We're just grateful for what time we can get to be alone when we can.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Wed, August 22, 2007 - 9:04 AM
      "the root of that issue comes from religious ideals that were drawn from a time period where rich men wanted to keep their wifes from having sex outside the marriage. So the made decrees and pass laws that said you can have sex outside of your own marriage."

      That's one theory on the root of the issue, there are many other theories that are just as likely. I've read quite a few of them but I'm not recalling a whole ton off the top of my head, it's not something that really pertains to my life as I have no desire to be monogamous.

      "P.S don't worry about people that are judging you, thats just a reflection for something they don't like in themselfs that is pretty similar to what you are going though right now. Its easy to say its wrong, but when you deep in the thick of it, it takes on a whole new meaning."

      First, not all judgments are because of a reflection of something inside themselves. People MUST make judgments in order to interact with the world, X is better than Y, Z is worse than A, ect. I feel that Munk is in a pretty bad situation because;
      She is involved in a relationship that is very likely going to be exposed.
      She has stated that both the husband and the wife are friends and that she wants to keep those friendships.
      If her relationship is exposed then she will likely lose the wife as a friend or at the very least lose that friends trust (which, IMO, renders the friendship null and void)
      The wife and husband will likely go through a very painful situation (and since they are both her friends why would it be ok to be a facilitator of a painful situation)

      Anyhow, some people probably are reacting in a more negative tone due to their experiences in the past (likely the ones who have been in the unknowing wife's position) but that is still valuable information for Munk since she has said she is friends with the wife and wants to remain friends with the wife.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Wed, August 22, 2007 - 11:41 AM
        Your points are not coming across to me because I don't feel like you can empathize with her position. She already knows its wrong, its not helping to give her a play by play breakdown of where she is wrong or me for that matter, and as I have said when you go around pointing out where people are wrong without someone giving you the go ahead you create the very thing that you want to avoid, which is the feeling superiority. (how are you feeling right now?)

        Also anything I say I was drawing from my own experiences your free to have your own, does it sound like im challenging you on them? The way you are talking about this whole subject just makes you look like you need to be right all the time, not someone I want to be around personally.

        Relax a little bit Steve, this is just a discussion not a place to feel better about your morals and values.

        If you continue your confrontational attitude in any more discussions with me, im going to ignore you like all the other guys that don't have their life together yet. Hopefully you are mature enough not to take this personally.
        • Re: Rules of Adultery?

          Wed, August 22, 2007 - 12:46 PM
          naughtalicous said:
          "Your points are not coming across to me because I don't feel like you can empathize with her position. She already knows its wrong, its not helping to give her a play by play breakdown of where she is wrong or me for that matter, and as I have said when you go around pointing out where people are wrong without someone giving you the go ahead you create the very thing that you want to avoid, which is the feeling superiority. (how are you feeling right now?)"

          It's not a very hard situation to empathize with, I'm pretty sure that most people have been involved in a situation where their actions would hurt a friend, perhaps even destroy that friendship, and were having difficulty dealing with the situation. The details may very well be different but the situation is similar enough for people to be able to see where she is coming from.

          I don't feel superior to Munk, I don't even know Munk. I am concerned that Munk is heading down a road that will likely lead to her losing her friendships.

          "The way you are talking about this whole subject just makes you look like you need to be right all the time, not someone I want to be around personally."

          I certainly don't need to be right and I hope I'm not right in this situation. However, from what Munk has said I can't see her keeping the friendship with the wife if things come out into the open and that seems like an untenable situation to me. Again, I could very well be wrong.

          Last, I'm not trying to be confrontational. I'm just trying to give advice, if it has come across as confrontational then I apologize and will endeavor to write in a way that has more clarity.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Thu, October 11, 2007 - 10:12 AM
      this is for naug....ohhhhhhhhhhhh,so its ok for kids to suffer on our needs............girl? have u ever been married? how old r u....? im sure u dont even have kids...sweetie ..ur point is clear...and maybe ur right in alot of ways..but it sounds very heartless..how can u do what ever u want..when u know in ur mind..its gonna hurt others? fuck the history lessen on what our parents told us.....we know whats right and wrong and if the fucker is not happy with his wife ..then he should leave her..
      the only thing ur telling me and everyone here..that its ok to hurt others when it comes to that issue.
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Wed, August 22, 2007 - 9:11 AM
    Also, please understand that I'm not trying to call you a terrible person, nor am I trying to be offensive. I'm trying to get my points across as clear as possible, you can ignore them, incorporate them, just read them or whatever.

    And, good luck, I hope things work out well.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Wed, August 22, 2007 - 1:16 PM
      I do understand your points and they did come off as a bit uppity to me. This whole situation has left me in a great deal of emotional turmoil and I hate feeling this way. It's not so easy to do the right thing even when you have the best intentions. When your head is being stern and logical but your heart is screaming and hanging on. Not an easy place to be. No matter what choice I make, eventualy someone will get hurt. If I end it myself I know I'll be nursing a broken heart for who knows how long. If we're unexpectedly found out, then we'll both be in the dog house. I would rather suffer alone than cause them any heartache. If I end it now no one I care about will be hurt and maybe, after some time to heal, I can find a guy to love freely and openly. That would be nice.
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Wed, August 22, 2007 - 11:51 AM
    The whole motto of this issue for some of you that like to point out the wrong doing of others is to let them figure that out or come to terms with it them selfs. If you talk about your own experiences when you were in a situation where you were not being honest with someone, its more likely that you are going to be heard. If you come from a place of superiority (this is how you should do this) to me that looks like a person that isn't comfortable enough in their own skin to let people make their own choices in life.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Wed, August 22, 2007 - 1:03 PM
      Naughtalicious,
      Well first as Steve pointed out many of us have been in one of those three positions - other person, cheating person, or cheated on person.

      Munk asked us for validation that what she was doing was ok. We couldn't provide it.

      Our feedback is not negative because we can't empathize or don't want her to figure it out for herself or need to feel superior or aren't ready to let her make her own choices in life.

      Our feedback is negative because it is the voice of experience - our experience. I have personally been in two of those positions - other person and cheated on person. And I have been in these positions in both monogamous and poly (with honesty) relationships. I have also been party in friendship to others in these roles. It never ends well when there is dishonesty and it is never ends well when rules of openness are broken with dishonesty. Period.

      Dishonesty leads to hurt and lost friendships. That's the way it works.

      If you can't accept our words of experience then perhaps you are still inexperienced in these ways. Give dishonesty a try and let us know how it turns out for you.
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Wed, August 22, 2007 - 1:25 PM
        I'm not looking for validation or an excuse to keep doing what I'm doing. I was asking about other peoples experiences, how they handled it, and how it ended or if it's still continuing. I understand the possible negative outcomes very well. But I have to learn and experience these things for myself and seeking the advice of others who have been there will help me on this journey. How it ends is completely up to me and I have no intention of conitinuing if it's going to potentialy hurt the ones I care about. I know honesty is important and it's bothered me from the beginning that he said we have to keep it a secret. I didn't like, I still don't , and I'm very quickly getting sick of it. I don't think I'll be willing to put up with it much longer anyway since it's not a fair position for me to be in.
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Wed, August 22, 2007 - 12:51 PM
    Well, my two cents:

    I personally would draw the line at having an FWB kind of thing with anyone who is in a relationship (married or not) unless that relationship is open in some way. And I'll be honest, more than just being an integrity thing (which it is) it is also for my own sanity. Hidden and secret relationships are guaranteed to be loaded with DRAMA, and that is something I just do not need.

    I think some people get off a bit on the naughtiness of doing something forbidden. I can totally understand how that could be a turn-on, but it's not something I would do.

    Perhaps, if you really really are serious about wanting to maintain this, he should seriously consider looking at Polyamory. But, at the least, if you truly think that he and his wife should be together, then there has to be some honesty. And the longer it goes on, the more painful the eventual ending (likely due to being discovered in some way) will be.

    My two cents: Make a pact to remain friends, but cut off the sexual side of it until you figure out how to do it the right way.

    Just my two cents!

    -craw
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Wed, August 22, 2007 - 1:07 PM
      Thanks you for replying. I do agree with you 100%. I've been looking into the poly lifestyle myself since it's something that interests me. We did make a pact in the beginning that we would remain friends even when this chapter of our lives is done. I'm quickly coming to terms with the fact that I don't like being in this type of situation because it really isn't fair to me. Having to keep it a secret as if we're horrible people, and we're not. I would just rather be friends than continue doing emotional damage to myself and potentialy to others.
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Thu, August 23, 2007 - 8:49 PM
    OK, here are some rules you're looking for:

    1) don't get caught
    2) don't sulk when he has to go back to his wife
    3) don't pressure him to leave his wife for you
    4) be aware that it will end, one way or another. If his marriage ends on its own accord, don't presume that he's yours.
    5) don't get caught
    6) don't put him in positions to get caught
    7) take care of yourself
    8) don't leave yourself so wrapped up on him that you won't take something "better" that comes along.
    9) don't get caught.
    10) practice safe sex & use birth control.
    11) discuss your options in the event of a pregnancy beforehands, and live up to them if it happens.
    12) let him have his time with his family, and don't interrupt it.
    13) if things get better with his marriage, or even if they just stay the same, don't sabotage it.
    14) don't get caught
    15) have great sex and don't let guilt slip into it. If this is what you want to do, then be true to yourself and enjoy it.
    16) communicate about the ongoing and changing state of the relationship.
    17) let it end if it's ending. It will hurt. get over it with dignity.
    18) remember that you are a fantasy, not a reality. be that fantasy.
    19) let him be your fantasy to you.
    And most importantly...
    20) DON'T GET CAUGHT.

    Good luck.
    • Re: Rules of Adultery?

      Thu, October 11, 2007 - 10:18 AM
      mike u r so funny..;-) hee-hee-hee but its a list to go by..(smile)
      • Re: Rules of Adultery?

        Fri, October 12, 2007 - 12:45 AM
        well, I hate to be the buzz kill, but I have to concur with Angel on this one..it seems like you are looking for someone to tell you that this is ok, and it's not.....and Angel made all the requisite points except one.

        Karma's a bitch babe. Consider that you are earning cosmic payback for yourself and ask yourself if you can live with that possibility - that someone you love and are in a committed relationship may one day be fucking someone behind your back. Maybe even your husband - the person you made vows with, the one you gave your whole self to, the one you thought you were going to spend the rest of your life loving in total trust.

        I'm ok with just about everything in the world, but adultery is one of the most damaging, destructive, and soul-killing activities there is. Ro everybody involved. And I'm not standing in a position of judgement, because I've done it. I've been all three people in Angel's scenario.

        Poly on the other hand, is friggin great. Why not be honest, live in integrity, feel good about yourself, and have whatever you want?
        • Re: Rules of Adultery?

          Sun, October 14, 2007 - 9:56 AM
          I don't see anything in her post looking for validation that it's OK. I read into it a strong realization that it's not OK, but it's where she wants to be regardless. Sometimes that happens; humans are messy that way.

          I don't approve of adultery, but I'm not going to claim that it doesn't have its upsides in certain situations for some people. Obvioutly she's playing with some very hot fire, and like any other fireplay, its a good idea to have some guidelines to keep yourself & others from getting burned.

          For you, adultery may be soul crushing, but that's not the case for everyone.
          • Re: Rules of Adultery?

            Thu, October 25, 2007 - 9:29 PM
            Really, the only rule is DON'T GET CAUGHT. Everything else flows from that, all the moralizing, breast-beating, howling about it all. One of my other rules would be DON'T DO IT WITH ANYONE YOUR SPOUSE KNOWS if you are married. DON'T DO IT WITH ANYONE WHOSE SPOUSE YOU ARE FRIENDS WITH. The whole point of adultery, as far as I can tell, is to do it, have fun doing it, and DON'T GET CAUGHT.
            Which may make you all think I do this a whole lot, which I don't. Just trying to join the conversation .....
  • Re: Rules of Adultery?

    Sat, November 3, 2007 - 7:30 PM
    I would suggest never having sex with a person who is married to someone you have some kind of relationship with (ie: a co-worker, a friend, a family member, etc)

    Aside from that, I say go for it. Their obligations are not your obligations, and if you play "holier than thou" and avoid sleeping with them, that's not going to save their marriage, they're just going to sleep with someone else. As far as I'm concerned, it might as well be you, lol.

    Hope it works out for you.

Recent topics in "Friends with benefits"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
single now Suzan-a-Thon 7 Yesterday, 8:47 PM
intimate friendship reggie 0 Yesterday, 4:57 PM
someone said In2wishn 12 December 30, 2009
LA Roll Call Gaston 5 December 28, 2009